<<back to news

More die as troops open fire on Mosul crowd
Michael Howard in Mosul and Rory McCarthy in Camp as-Sayliya, Qatar
Thursday April 17, 2003
The Guardian

Community leaders in Mosul appealed for calm yesterday after US forces became involved in a lethal firefight in the city centre for the second day running.

Doctors at Mosul's emergency hospital said at least three people were killed and 12 injured, including two children, after US troops responded to what a military spokesmen described as "aimed fire".

On Tuesday 10 people were killed and at least 16 wounded in a similar incident.

Residents angered by two days of shootings accused US soldiers involved in yesterday's event of firing deliberately at a crowd of civilians gathered near the governor's building in the city's central administrative district.

But Captain Frank Thorp, a spokesman for US central command in Qatar, vehemently denied the claim. "It absolutely didn't happen," he said. Marines who were securing the governor's building had opened fire, he said, but they were aiming above the crowd at gunmen who were sniping from a rooftop. "The marines were fired upon... away from the crowd," Capt Thorp said. "They fired back, but they never fired at the crowd."

He added that the shooting ended as soon as the marines returned fire: "It had nothing to do with the crowd."

Another version came from Mahmoud Ahmed, a retired Iraqi military general, who witnessed the incident. He said that at the time of the shooting, Mosul police were trying to prevent looters from stealing money from the city's nearby central bank.

He said police had fired a number of times into the air to scatter the looters and that US soldiers opened fire, believing they were under attack.

"I heard three shots from the bank," he said. "Then the Americans opened fire. They sprayed the area. They must have fired 1,000 rounds. But they didn't seem to fire at the bank, they fired in the direction of the crowd by the governor's office."

Amar Ghanem Abdullah, 25, who was wounded in both legs, was among police ordered to stop the looting. He said the police shot in the air to disperse the crowd, and then the Americans fired from the roof of the governor's building.

The Americans "thought we were shooting at them... I don't think they were shooting at us deliberately."

The shooting follows Tuesday's violence in which protesters hurled rocks and fired at US soldiers protecting Mashaan al-Juburi, an Iraqi opposition figure and would-be Mosul governor, who gave an address at the governor's building.

The appearance of Mr Juburi, a former Republican Guard commander, appeared to goad the crowd. Eyewitnesses say the mood of the crowd turned when Mr Juburi hailed the arrival of American forces in Mosul and US troops hoisted an American flag above the governor's building.

US officials yesterday admitted their troops had fired at demonstrators in Mosul on Tuesday, but claimed that gunmen in the crowd had been trying to stage an assault on a building where US forces were meeting local leaders.

Brigadier-General Vince Brooks, deputy director of operations at central command, said he believed seven people had been killed in the incident. US special forces and marines were in the governor's building at the time.

"The crowd was violent, throwing rocks at the marines, hitting them with fists and spitting on them," Gen Brooks said. An ambulance drove outside with a loudspeaker "to incense the crowd", he said.

The gun battles are a blow to US efforts to restore normality to the streets of Iraq's third largest city after six days of looting and unrest that followed the collapse of the Ba'athist administration.

Colonel Robert Waltemeyer, who heads US operations in Mosul, said it was vital to establish security in the city, but that the US was not there to impose military rule.

US special forces, which have been bolstered by several thousand marines, say they are trying to encourage staff in the municipal services to get the city back up and running again. A representative body of tribal, religious and civic leaders is expected to convene tomorrow.

But yesterday the centre of Mosul looked more like a Beirut war zone than a liberated city. Known as a Saddam stronghold, it is believed to harbour members of Iraq's former leadership as well as die-hard Ba'athists. The recent uncertainty raised the possibilityof inter-tribal and inter-ethnic clashes between the city's majority Sunni Arab and minority Kurdish communities.

The looting of a large arsenal the day after the fall of the city means there are also thousands of guns on Mosul's streets.