<<back to news

Israel, China Cited for Right Abuses
By SONYA ROSS
The Associated Press
Tuesday, April 1, 2003; 2:31 AM
 

Some of the countries supporting U.S.-led efforts to oust Saddam Hussein score a below-par human rights performance in the State Department's annual human rights report, while others get a passing grade.

The report, published Monday, also described the protracted conflict between Israel and the Palestinians as rife with "numerous, serious human rights abuses" during 2002, while China maintained its less-than-stellar rights record.

Among supporters of the war against Iraq, the already poor record of the Eritrean government worsened, the report said, and Uzbekistan earned a "very poor" rating even though there were some notable improvements.

Qatar and Kuwait, also supporters of the war, were said to be generally respectful of their citizens - as were Germany and France, two countries most identified with opposing the war.

The U.S.-led coalition in Iraq is liberating that country from a "ruthless tyranny that has shown utter contempt for human life," Secretary of State Colin Powell told reporters Monday. He pledged to help ordinary Iraqis create a "representative democracy that respects the rights of all of its citizens."

On Israel, the report said the country's overall human rights record in the occupied territories remained poor, and worsened in several areas as it continued to commit "numerous, serious human rights abuses."

"Security forces killed at least 990 Palestinians and two foreign nationals and injured 4,382 Palestinians and other persons during the year, including innocent bystanders," the report said.

It said Israeli security forces targeted and killed at least 37 Palestinian terror suspects.

"Israeli forces undertook some of these targeted killings in crowded areas when civilian casualties were likely, killing 25 bystanders, including 13 children," the report said.

It noted that the Israeli government said that it made every effort to reduce civilian casualties during these operations.

The report said many members of Palestinian security services and the Fatah faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization participated with civilians and terrorist groups in violent attacks against Israeli settlers, other civilians and soldiers.

Although there was no conclusive evidence that the most senior PLO or Palestinian Authority leaders gave prior approval for these acts, the report said some leaders endorsed such acts in principle in speeches and interviews.

On China, the report said abuses included "instances of extrajudicial killings, torture and mistreatment of prisoners, forced confessions, arbitrary arrest and detention, lengthy incommunicado detention and denial of due process."

At the same time, the report credited the government with some positive steps, including the release of a number of prominent dissidents and the granting of permission for senior representatives of the Dalai Lama to visit the country.

The administration usually attempts to censure China on human rights at the annual meeting of the U.N. Human Rights Commission in Geneva. The meeting is now in its third week, and Powell declined on Monday to say whether Washington will introduce a China resolution at the commission meeting.

The report noted religious harassment in Russia, but praised President Vladimir Putin's government for installing a new criminal code that, for the first time, established that people could be arrested or detained only through judicial decision.

"The changes appeared to be having an effect on police, prosecutorial behavior and the judicial system, although there were reports of noncompliance in some regions," the report said.

The report, covering almost 200 countries, said respect for human rights was generally good in Latin America but it listed six countries where rights conditions were listed as "poor" -- Colombia, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, El Salvador and Venezuela.

In Pakistan, a key ally in the war on terrorism, the report said the government's rights record remained poor. "In general police continued to commit serious abuses with impunity," it said.